California Lawyers > Employment Lawyer > Employment Whistle Blowing Lawyer > Ethics Of Whistle Blowing |
Ethics Of Whistle Blowing |
|
When an employee discovers
immoral, illegal or unethical actions at work, the employee makes a
decision about what to do with this information. Whistle blowing is the
term used to define an employee’s decision to disclose this information
to an authority figure. Whistle blowing leads to good and bad results.
The benefits of a carefully considered whistle blowing can lead to the
end of unethical business practices.
The ethics of whistle blowing has normally been
deemed negatively. Workers are often torn between their moral and legal
obligation to report any irregular activities and their loyalty towards
their companies. To save employees from such a critical choice,
companies should institute a formal ethics of whistle blowing mechanism
wherein employees can freely report irregularities. A company that
refuses to do something about a reported illegal activity is guilty of
tolerance. In such cases, whistle-blowing may be the most ethically
practical action.
The issue of the proper ethics of whistle blowing is
troubling because there is an inherent conflict between an employee's
loyalty to the organization and the employee's potential legal
obligation to report apparently fraudulent activities to the proper
authorities. Complicating the matter concerning the ethics of whistle
blowing is the potential for significant financial gain for the
whistle-blower if he or she does report such activities.
Whistle blowing would seem to be an act of
remarkable moral courage. Indeed, if whistle blowing is dependent
solely on individual conscientiousness or self-sacrifice in the face of
indifference or retaliation, then such acts will remain relatively
rare. In examining the ethics of whistle blowing it is important to
consider the objections of the “moral hero” myth, before considering a
moral assessment, and conclusion can be made.
Whistle blowing has several objections from various
moral agents that are critical to evaluating on the basis of the ethics
of whistle blowing. From the business organization’s perspective,
it is unethical for an employee to leak confidential information
outside of the organization. Thus, the act of whistle blowing may be
morally justified as an individual obligation to act. Throughout
history, there have been no known societies which do not contain moral
codes against harming others.
However, when considering disclosing information
that would be deemed detrimental to the company you must take into
consideration the ethics of whistle blowing and seeking the advice of
competent lawyer to protect your rights and legal options.
Hence, this ethics of whistle blowing might then
impact how individuals perceive their moral responsibilities and
support a conception of whistle blowing, not as an act of disloyalty,
but as an act of virtue.
|
|